并排对比
部门决定采用的功能行 —— 包括我们失去的部分。
| 功能 | Yoshuko | Canvas | Blackboard |
|---|---|---|---|
| 教学负担 | |||
| 长篇答案的人工智能批改 | Marked against the teacher's own rubric, on every plan | 手动 — 按评分标准人工批改 | 手动 — 按评分标准人工批改 |
| AI reads work written by hand from a photo | 学员拍摄页面；文字将被评分 | 手动 — 上传照片并目视标记 | 手动 — 上传照片并目视标记 |
| 学术标准 | |||
| AI checks written work for AI use | Every plan, with a level set per course | 手动 — 您自行评判，或购买附加功能 | 手动 — 您自行评判，或购买附加功能 |
| Checking written work for copying | 所有套餐均包含 | 通过付费第三方插件 | SafeAssign 已包含 |
| Rubrics you can use again across a course | Saved as templates, changed in the lesson | 课程级评分标准 | 课程级评分标准 |
| 通过扫描 QR 工牌进行出勤 | 打印工牌或学员应用代码，在门口读取 | 点名，或第三方工具 | 点名，或第三方工具 |
| 进进出出 | |||
| 导入现有课程 | Canvas, Blackboard, Brightspace, Schoology and Moodle archives | 通用课程包和 Moodle | 通用课程包 |
| 导出整个课程 | 通用课程包 1.3 和 SCORM 1.2，随时可用 | 通用课程包 | 通用课程包 |
| 公开定价 | 已发布的价格计划；从一门课程开始 | 按机构报价；未发布 | 按机构报价；未发布 |
| 他们领先的地方 | |||
| 讨论区和社区 | A board per course that staff can manage; not graded, no groups | 内置功能 | 内置功能 |
| 应用商店中的手机和平板应用程序 | 学员应用可在任何浏览器中运行 | 已发布的 iOS 和 Android 应用程序 | 已发布的 iOS 和 Android 应用程序 |
Canvas and Blackboard sell on contracts with each institution and publish no list price, so no price is claimed for either. 关于 Canvas 和 Blackboard 的声明，最近审核时间为 August 2026。
在 Canvas 和 Blackboard 仍领先或持平的方面
如果其中任何一项决定了您的选择，那它应该如此。您在这里阅读比在试点中发现要好得多。
单点登录和学生记录
Canvas and Blackboard connect to your single sign-on (SSO, SAML) and your student records system (SIS). Yoshuko does neither, so accounts and course places are managed in Yoshuko. That is fine for a department and a real cost across a whole institution.
其他公司的LTI工具
二十年来，LTI工具可插进Canvas和Blackboard。Yoshuko不支持LTI，因此你已许可的工具不会出现在Yoshuko课程内。
远程监考考试
There are no online exams watched by a person here, and no partners who do it. If a programme depends on exams watched that way, that stays where it is.
Copied work checking at no extra cost
SafeAssign 随 Blackboard 提供。我们的也包含——这是我们要画的一行，而非我们能赢的。
Range, and a large community
Canvas does more things than Yoshuko does, and there is an answer online for most of them. A newer platform cannot claim that and should not pretend to.
为什么高校或培训机构仍会选择迁移
八个论点，每个都是平台已有的功能。
Comments arrive while they can still change the grade
Written work is marked against the teacher's own rubric within hours, not at the end of two weeks of marking. Fast comments are the most widely agreed way to raise achievement, and a pile of work waiting to be marked takes them away.
您在第三周看到学生落后，而非等到结果出来才知
Progress and drop-off are tracked per cohort inside a course, so a teacher can act while there is still term left. How many students complete the course, and how many graduate, is decided in week three, not in the results.
出勤不再占用每课时的五分钟
Learners hold up a printed badge or the code in their app and the register fills itself as the class arrives. Across a timetable that is teaching time returned, and the data is good enough to act on.
Honest work without a second contract
Checks for AI-written and copied work run on every marked answer, with the level set per course. Elsewhere this is a separate product, a separate purchase and a separate contract to sign again each year.
纸张仍然有效
Students photograph pages written by hand and the typed-up text is graded like any other answer. Nothing else in this category does that, and it matters wherever mathematics, science or exam practice is still done on paper.
将您现有的课程带入系统
Canvas, Blackboard, Brightspace, Schoology and Moodle archives import directly — units, pages, quiz questions and answer keys. The reason departments stay where they are is the cost of moving, and that is the cost this removes.
并留下他们
每个课程均可随时导出为 Common Cartridge 1.3 或 SCORM 1.2 格式。一个易于离开的平台，是您可以在一学期内采用它，而非依赖五年规划来决定是否采纳。
一个部门即可批准
Published prices and no long set-up project mean a single department can run a real term and report a real result. That is a change somebody inside the institution can put their name to — and stop, cheaply, if it does not work.
从一个部门开始
- 导出一门课程 Take it out of Canvas or Blackboard as Common Cartridge and import it here. Units, pages, quiz questions and answer keys come across.
- 运行一个学期 Teachers mark against their own rubrics; the AI does the first pass and they change whatever they disagree with.
- 对比结果 Set it beside the department next door — how fast work is marked, attendance, drop-off. Then decide.
没有任何锁定内容。您随时可以将任何课程导出为Common Cartridge或SCORM格式。